Survivor Allstars 2?

[Big Tom]

Stephenie and Bobby Jon should NOT be back.

They've already had 2 chances to play. No more.

[Patricia♥Jackson]

BJ and Steph are overrated in my opinion! And I agree with you Big Tom, they should NOT be brought back.

[Joel Klug]

Yeah, I've had more than enough of BJ and Stephenie. Thank you.

Also, Jonathan and James! YES!

I also am not fond of Todd.. or Amanda.. or even Courtney. I can't stand that alliance altogether. They think they own the game, especially Todd.

[Jessie Camacho]

I really liked Eliza and Cirie I hope they are back.

[Stacey Stillman]

Though the list have some of my favourite survivors, I'm not a big fan with all stars season, the winners are always those I don't like very much.

[Maralyn Hershey]

I don't think any winners will be back. :]
I don't want immunity hogs in the game [Ozzy/Terry/Tom] because it makes the game a bit less enjoyable. I'd rather see Yau Man win the wrestling competition.

[Patricia♥Jackson]

OH! I believe..

-Ami
-Eliza
-Parvati
-Jonathan
-Yau Man
-Ozzy
-Jonny Fairplay


Those are names that I've heard are coming back into the Allstars 2.
I know that Rita Verreos and Coby Archa were considered but not niched at the last minute, same with Michelle Yi! boo.

[Patricia♥Jackson]

Cast {Potential}:

Eliza, Jonathan, JFP, Yau Man, Ami, Parvati, Courtney (or) Amanda, James, Ozzy.

[Joel Klug]

God I hope it's not Courtney. I hate her.

Also, I heard it's All Stars vs. new people. I'd much rather prefer an All Stars post jury vs. Pre jury returnees from any season. Guys like Jeff Wilson who got a tough break and deserve a second go.

[Geust]

If anyone wants to see a website with the Survivor All Star 2 Contestant, here you go.

survivorwiki.cbs.com/page/Survivor+All+Stars+2+Scoreboard+-+Actual+Contestants

[Joel Klug]

That list is clearly made up.

For one, Jonny Fairplay has been 100% confirmed. Another is that a bunch of those people are partaking in the dodgeball tournament like Judd and others like Terry are blogging on CBS. I don't believe that at all.

[Maralyn Hershey]

Do you have a source for JFP? I don't think he'd be in it... he was pre S8, which is a little unfair. I mean, he could have taken Amber's place...

[Joanna Ward]

Johnny Fairplay should NOT come back. He built up a great reputation in Pearl Islands. If he comes back, I guarantee you he'll be one of the first three booted.

I'm starting to think I don't like the concept behind Survivor All-Stars anyway. After they go on the show, they all re-enter reality but come back as best friends. For all we know, these guys all hung out together the week before leaving for the taping of it. It's kinda rediculous now. They all know each other already and have developed opinions of one another. Why even do this?

[Maralyn Hershey]

Ratings.

[Joel Klug]

maralyn said:

Ratings.

Ding ding ding!

Also, JFP is confirmed by Coby from Palau who has also spoiled numerous others in the cast. JFP is one of the people he's 100% sure of.